|
Post by Oliver on Nov 24, 2021 22:11:33 GMT
I don’t think there’s anything cryptic about that. She is basically dissing her boss, the person we are led to believe hired her for Cinderella, a powerful producer and a legend of musical theatre. Good luck with the future career Carrie. I'm astonished anyone is defending ALW's behaviour. Without all of these performers he wouldn't have a show. Just because they are a much lower rung of the ladder doesn't mean he gets to treat them like dirt. It's pathetic. And to say don't bite the hand that feeds you is also astonishing and perpetuates the problem - if people don't stand up for themselves nothing will ever change, and sometimes standing up for oneself publicly is absolutely necessary, especially when there is such a huge imbalance of power. So these performers are beyond criticism are they? Someone can never criticise anyone in their employ simply because there's a power differential? How is making a comment that people should not take the industry for granted, including himself, treating them like dirt? Do you know all the ins and outs of this conversation, have you been privy to everything that has been said in order that you can form an objective assessment of the situation and decide who is in the right? The "without all these performers he wouldn't have a show" is silly. You could just as easily turn that around and say that without him they wouldn't get to be in the show.
|
|
913 posts
|
Post by karloscar on Nov 24, 2021 22:18:46 GMT
Your complaint was about a plot point: the Fairy Godmother's warning to Cinderella to be home by midnight and there being no suitable pay-off for that in act 2. I was pointing out that this is in fact the fault of the book writer and not the lyricist. You are conflating one with the other. With regard to the lyrics above, I like these, especially "just like that goddess from Greece, you know, who launched all the ships". I especially like the casual throwaway "you know" which is most effective here. The last line is great, "disappear me", things don't always need to make literal sense or conform to strict grammatical rules. It's a case of when and how. Helen of Troy wasn't even a goddess in the first place, but is that the ignorance of the character or the lyricist? Hahaha.
|
|
|
Post by pomegranate on Nov 24, 2021 22:23:17 GMT
If ALW keeps carrying on like this his reputation is going to come crashing down like a chandelier… no pun intended
|
|
2,394 posts
|
Post by theatreian on Nov 24, 2021 22:23:49 GMT
TBH neither Carrie nor ALW are covering themselves in glory, they're using their particular outlets in the wrong way. That's how it appears to me and it shows the very worst aspects of social media in that people day things without thinking through the consequences and once they are in writing then damage is done. It does the show no favours either. As to the offer for December I'm sure there are a lot of shows that will suffer this December more than the average December due to the reduction in tourizst numbers. There aren't going to be vast numbers here as is normal.
|
|
1,482 posts
|
Post by steve10086 on Nov 24, 2021 22:29:54 GMT
Such a shame that back in the 90’s ALW would fall out with proper Grade A Broadway stars… and now it’s a vlogger. Standards have slipped.
|
|
|
Post by max on Nov 24, 2021 22:33:51 GMT
As mentioned above, it takes a particular 'talent' to turn the good news stories of the charity benefit performance and the Grammy nomination into a VERY bad news week. Looking at the Twitter 'likes' CHF has given to various tweets, some are quite extreme from others in the industry. It's v much a 'so it is to be war between us' moment. At least two other 'Cinderella' cast members have commented on or retweeted CHF's repeat of her earlier statement.
It's clear that a number of people are not scared, and would take being sacked if it came to it - probably with an awareness that there would be an unfair dismissal process to follow if so.
This feels like ALW, unable to apologise for his phoned-in cast critique of a few weeks ago, has committed to doubling down on those comments instead. Either to make himself believe they were justified, or because he genuinely believes they were. Even if the latter, this is never how it should be handled. I should think the staff director, and any staff producer from RUG must feel very aggrieved it didn't go through them instead, and that their skills could have saved this.
CHF and the others have absolutely nothing to fear re career damage. There's a new breed of performer: in-tune / self-care aware / too fragile / millennial / up themselves, call it what you will; but they're going to set the future of how relationships are contracted in the theatre, for good or ill.
With great irony, I expect many of them to find a warm home at The Other Palace, and plenty of opportunities from a new breed of producers there and beyond.
I picture Debbie Allen in the opening frames of the TV show 'Fame', banging her dancing stick fearsomely. "You want fame, well fame costs, and right here is where you start paying - in sweat". Today a student would grab it off her, snap it in half, and tell her to "do one". Before marching of to the principal's office to get the relevant policy and complaint form.
ALW's behaviour (whether his views are right or wrong) is idiotic. I find it very sad that so late in his career/life he's burned his reputation with the current/future crop of performers, but he clearly has.
I can imagine this being his last show.
|
|
5,877 posts
|
Post by mrbarnaby on Nov 24, 2021 22:44:42 GMT
I’ve missed all this. What did he say?
|
|
|
Post by stagebyte on Nov 24, 2021 22:50:21 GMT
I’ve missed all this. What did he say? Ok so this is what the actual article said. Wonder how many on Twitter have read it or just reacting? ‘Andrew Lloyd Webber has accused younger cast members in his musical Cinderella of failing to remember they work in the “service industry”, adding that “nobody has a right to be on the stage”. In what appeared to be a criticism of the attitude of actors in his show, he addressed claims that he had “berated” the cast following a bad review in the New York Post, according to a report in the Daily Mail. Lloyd Webber told Samira Ahmed on BBC Radio 4’s Front Row that he did address the cast, but that it had “nothing to do with the New York Post”. “What I was saying to everybody is, the younger cast don’t really realise all the time [that] we are a service industry, and nobody has a right to be on the stage. I don’t have a right to have my musicals in the theatre,” he said, adding: “What we have to do is try to give the best performances possible. All I was saying is, that is what we have to do and the cast we have at Cinderella are really wonderful and are well capable of doing that. But this has been wildly exaggerated.” He denied that there would be major changes to the musical following the review in the New York Post, but said there would be some tweaks, amounting to cuts of about two or three minutes. He added that the Broadway version of Cinderella would not be able to be staged as it is in London, because the Gillian Lynne Theatre has a revolve, of which the musical makes use. He said in New York it would be performed in a “different configuration”.
|
|
|
Post by max on Nov 24, 2021 22:58:59 GMT
One further thought: it's often said that novelists fear having based a character on someone close to them; but then find it's all fine, because the person sees NONE of the negative traits, and so didn't even recognise themselves in the book.
ALW can't see himself in his own musicals. Particularly extraordinary as he's written at least four with the same story dynamic, about a creative person who finds a younger muse figure, and tension results. None of them end well:
*THE PHANTOM OF THE OPERA - muse absconds with regret (and the romantic lead), Svengali figure disappears. *SUNSET BOULEVARD - older creative finds younger one to confer 'relevance', but captures rather than honours his talent (and he thinks of it as a hack job anyway). Result: mutual destruction. *WHISTLE DOWN THE WIND - muse grows up and sees Svengali was 'just a fella', fella either dead in fire or disappears. *STEPHEN WARD - muse reputation tarnished, Svengali figure dead.
*LOVE NEVER DIES - rematch where escapee muse 'gets it' after all (and not in a 'Beneath A Moonless Sky' way).
|
|
|
Post by Oliver on Nov 24, 2021 23:01:01 GMT
Your complaint was about a plot point: the Fairy Godmother's warning to Cinderella to be home by midnight and there being no suitable pay-off for that in act 2. I was pointing out that this is in fact the fault of the book writer and not the lyricist. You are conflating one with the other. With regard to the lyrics above, I like these, especially "just like that goddess from Greece, you know, who launched all the ships". I especially like the casual throwaway "you know" which is most effective here. The last line is great, "disappear me", things don't always need to make literal sense or conform to strict grammatical rules. It's a case of when and how. Helen of Troy wasn't even a goddess in the first place, but is that the ignorance of the character or the lyricist? Hahaha. Neither, it's the other meaning of "goddess" that is being used here, a woman who is greatly admired for her beauty and influence. It's also very much in keeping with Cinderella's character that she would see her as one.
|
|
3,473 posts
Member is Online
|
Post by ceebee on Nov 24, 2021 23:01:50 GMT
I began as an advocate for this show. Despite its obvious flaws, I preferred to focus on the post-lockdown positives of new theatre. However, the current mudslinging has put me off going again. I wonder if they realise how vacuous the current spat makes them all look. People are still struggling with covid, post-lockdown financial recovery, anxiety about public health etc. and this lot are behaving like bratty divas. ALW should know better, CHF should look beyond this contract, and Cinderella should perhaps just close and hand over the Gillian Lynne Theatre to a 50th year revival of the OAT JCS which would surely make many people happier than this current sideshow.
|
|
254 posts
|
Post by lolalou on Nov 24, 2021 23:03:55 GMT
Helen of Troy wasn't even a goddess in the first place, but is that the ignorance of the character or the lyricist? Hahaha. Neither, it's the other meaning of "goddess" that is being used here, a woman who is greatly admired for her beauty and influence. It's also very much in keeping with Cinderella's character that she would see her as one. You are so knowledgeable about this show Oliver I would love for you to reveal you’re Andy Himself. Can you let us know what the focaccia is going on? Because this drama is shaping up to be better than the show script.
|
|
7,156 posts
Member is Online
|
Post by Jon on Nov 24, 2021 23:06:07 GMT
Having listened to the Front Row interview, ALW doesn't come out of it smelling of roses.
|
|
5,877 posts
|
Post by mrbarnaby on Nov 24, 2021 23:07:20 GMT
This show will die a death in NYC , they are mad to take it there.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 24, 2021 23:12:08 GMT
I'm astonished anyone is defending ALW's behaviour. Without all of these performers he wouldn't have a show. Just because they are a much lower rung of the ladder doesn't mean he gets to treat them like dirt. It's pathetic. And to say don't bite the hand that feeds you is also astonishing and perpetuates the problem - if people don't stand up for themselves nothing will ever change, and sometimes standing up for oneself publicly is absolutely necessary, especially when there is such a huge imbalance of power. So these performers are beyond criticism are they? Someone can never criticise anyone in their employ simply because there's a power differential? How is making a comment that people should not take the industry for granted, including himself, treating them like dirt? Do you know all the ins and outs of this conversation, have you been privy to everything that has been said in order that you can form an objective assessment of the situation and decide who is in the right? The "without all these performers he wouldn't have a show" is silly. You could just as easily turn that around and say that without him they wouldn't get to be in the show. Oh wow you really do love to misinterpret what people say to suit your blind love of ALW. And hypocritical to the extreme with your comments about objective assessment...! No-one is beyond appropriate criticism, but publicly insulting the cast of your production is immature, inappropriate and just plain rude.
|
|
5,877 posts
|
Post by mrbarnaby on Nov 24, 2021 23:14:51 GMT
His comments on masks in theatres are absolutely spineless. He could absolutely enforce it. So could Moulin Rouge- and they aren’t. It’s all hot air, and desperately frustrating considering the tough time theatre has had.
|
|
|
Post by stagebyte on Nov 24, 2021 23:15:53 GMT
|
|
|
Post by cezbear on Nov 24, 2021 23:19:07 GMT
Look. I know this probably won't make any difference and I'm wasting my time. But I'd really love to see less of the crowing at the possibility of the show not doing well. You don't like it fine, but plenty do. And more importantly: these are people's jobs. For many they are living their dream, some of the cast are in their first west end roles. Gloating at any possible misfortune is just petty and unfair. And yes ALW has clearly been an idiot and disrespectful, and yes CHF has most likely brought all this about and is continuing to make it worse with every liked tweet. We don't all need to pile on though.
|
|
|
Post by Oliver on Nov 24, 2021 23:21:32 GMT
So these performers are beyond criticism are they? Someone can never criticise anyone in their employ simply because there's a power differential? How is making a comment that people should not take the industry for granted, including himself, treating them like dirt? Do you know all the ins and outs of this conversation, have you been privy to everything that has been said in order that you can form an objective assessment of the situation and decide who is in the right? The "without all these performers he wouldn't have a show" is silly. You could just as easily turn that around and say that without him they wouldn't get to be in the show. Oh wow you really do love to misinterpret what people say to suit your blind love of ALW. And hypocritical to the extreme with your comments about objective assessment...! No-one is beyond appropriate criticism, but publicly insulting the cast of your production is immature, inappropriate and just plain rude. He didn't do it publicly, this was leaked to the popular press who then blew it out of all proportion.
|
|
7,156 posts
Member is Online
|
Post by Jon on Nov 24, 2021 23:23:53 GMT
I struggle to see where on Broadway it could go as it would swallowed by the likes of the Broadway Theatre and the St James Theatre which are the only decent sized theatres available.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 24, 2021 23:25:31 GMT
Your complaint was about a plot point: the Fairy Godmother's warning to Cinderella to be home by midnight and there being no suitable pay-off for that in act 2. I was pointing out that this is in fact the fault of the book writer and not the lyricist. You are conflating one with the other. With regard to the lyrics above, I like these, especially "just like that goddess from Greece, you know, who launched all the ships". I especially like the casual throwaway "you know" which is most effective here. The last line is great, "disappear me", things don't always need to make literal sense or conform to strict grammatical rules. It's a case of when and how. Oliver, i applaud the way you try and claim someone was talking about something else, when you don't have a good response to the initial thread, something you have done a few times. You know I was talking about the lyrics. And once again, you are making a statement like you know it all. You are truely deluded. It must be nice to be that oblivious sometimes.
|
|
|
Post by max on Nov 24, 2021 23:28:45 GMT
Look. I know this probably won't make any difference and I'm wasting my time. But I'd really love to see less of the crowing at the possibility of the show not doing well. You don't like it fine, but plenty do. And more importantly: these are people's jobs. For many they are living their dream, some of the cast are in their first west end roles. Gloating at any possible misfortune is just petty and unfair. And yes ALW has clearly been an idiot and disrespectful, and yes CHF has most likely brought all this about and is continuing to make it worse with every liked tweet. We don't all need to pile on though. I've seen what I felt were pile ons in this place, and have spoken up - but I don't see one here really. ALW has gone onto BBC Radio 4 and told potential audiences that he reckons sometimes his 'Cinderella' cast don't give it their all. He's piled on. Also - I think this does have a material effect on the West End & Broadway transfer success/failure, because HE has made it a subject of speculation, that the show is volatile. He's pinned that on the cast, but investors, critics, and audiences in New York will now be attuned to looking at whether the cast really were the problem. As a frothy night out, I'm not sure there ever was a big problem. I've been on here many times citing ecstatic tweets from audience members. I read them daily. I think it's mainly long standing ALW fans on here (rather than his serial detractors) who were disappointed (even angry) the standard wasn't higher. I don't want to insult other people's favourite shows on here, but I see other similarly commercial work getting what feels like a free pass (or at least an easier ride). BUT he has now created a situation where it will need to be BRILLIANT to counteract the negative spotlight and scepticism that he is most responsible for casting onto it. That may now prove too much to get it to Broadway.
|
|
4,800 posts
|
Post by Mark on Nov 24, 2021 23:34:12 GMT
Was there at the matinee today. Georgina as Cinderella and Michael as Sebastian. They were both great. Any comments made have clearly not rubbed off on the cast - they're all putting their hearts and soul into this show.
|
|
|
Post by fiyerorocher on Nov 24, 2021 23:36:52 GMT
Changes made post-gala night are minimal: - Pre show pre-recorded message from ALW. Gives background on Belleville being full of beautiful people (never a good sign when your show needs pre-show material to make sense *cough* Bat Out Of Hell *cough*...) and very strongly expressing that there IS a live orchestra even if you can't see them... -Line changes in Act 1. Largely to the Queen's dialogue. Clearly they caught on that there are plot holes, but it doesn't feel like they were really listening. The line changes are all stressing the link between losing the prize for most picturesque town and then having no money and needing some good PR. But no one was ever confused about that. Now it just feels like they're treating the audience like they're stupid and hitting them over the head with the message, but they're also leaving in all the actual plot holes, e.g.: the Godmother, and the Queen and the Stepmother knowing each other -No real changes to any of the songs in Act 1. Dialogue cut from the scene just before So Long (a mistake. you lose a lot of their friendship). Some lines of the Godmother's cut before Beauty Has A Price (probably for the best. she did go on a little). Most of the line changes don't achieve much, if anything. Many are actively worse. -Very few changes in Act 2. Everything is pretty much exactly the same until the Cinderella Soliloquy, which cuts the I Know I Have a Heart section. Edit: you also now get emailed a survey asking you why you saw Cinderella, what you thought of the show, and what newspapers you read and radio stations you listen to?
|
|
|
Post by fiyerorocher on Nov 24, 2021 23:39:12 GMT
Also the first time I've seen Michael as Sebastian since he was thrown into covering a recovering-from-surgery Ivano, and he's come on leaps and bounds. Was a little ambivalent to his take on the role before, but now I really like it. He even distracted the people next to me from their constant talking and got them on board with his performance :')
|
|