1,558 posts
|
Post by showtoones on Oct 17, 2024 15:46:20 GMT
I think the casting is very interesting but it’s just not a good show. The songs are not tuneful and the story is very hard to follow. Maybe the Donmar will do a better production that was on Broadway, but I was really underwhelmed and it was just quite boring.
|
|
252 posts
|
Post by frankubelik on Oct 17, 2024 16:14:50 GMT
I recall struggling with the score on first hearing it. Booked (as a Donmar Friend) but now on a second listen, might be returning tickets! It's not very good - can someone convince me otherwise? ?
|
|
|
Post by Afriley on Oct 17, 2024 16:23:24 GMT
I recall struggling with the score on first hearing it. Booked (as a Donmar Friend) but now on a second listen, might be returning tickets! It's not very good - can someone convince me otherwise? ? Nah it’s awful. Can I buy your ticket? 😂
|
|
|
Post by colorthehours048 on Oct 17, 2024 17:37:35 GMT
I found the score mostly impenetrable when I saw it off-Broadway in the tent on 45th Street, but thought the work done on it between then and the Broadway mounting (combined with the staging of it on Broadway) was a great improvement. Just small cuts and added music to make it a little less challenging on the ears. Now it’s one of my all-time favorite scores.
I will say that my enjoyment of it increased after seeing it on Broadway, so if you’re not sure how you’re feeling just based on a listen, the production could still win you over. The direction and performances may make all the difference.
|
|
5,738 posts
|
Post by mrbarnaby on Oct 17, 2024 18:03:16 GMT
Delighted about Maimuna and Jamie Muscato. Less so Cedric Neal.
|
|
1,558 posts
|
Post by showtoones on Oct 17, 2024 18:12:21 GMT
Delighted about Maimuna and Jamie Muscato. Less so Cedric Neal. They could put Dame Judi and Johnny Bailey in the show and I wouldn’t go see it lol
|
|
5,738 posts
|
Post by mrbarnaby on Oct 17, 2024 21:27:49 GMT
Delighted about Maimuna and Jamie Muscato. Less so Cedric Neal. They could put Dame Judi and Johnny Bailey in the show and I wouldn’t go see it lol So the question is- why are you lurking in this thread?
|
|
|
Post by osdtdg on Oct 17, 2024 21:29:25 GMT
I think this is the type of show that requires a second viewing to get your head around it. Or, that is, the first time you will probably be quite confused but the second will give you a better understanding while you are able to focus more on comprehending everything already being familiar with the show. At least, thats how it was for me when I saw it in Sydney
|
|
|
Post by ThereWillBeSun on Oct 17, 2024 23:25:30 GMT
I think this is the type of show that requires a second viewing to get your head around it. Or, that is, the first time you will probably be quite confused but the second will give you a better understanding while you are able to focus more on comprehending everything already being familiar with the show. At least, thats how it was for me when I saw it in Sydney Agreed. Saw it in NYC and the story just felt odd. But the best sound design I’ve ever seen and the production design was opulent / gorgeous in the round. The cast recording make me really grow to love it. Are we supposed to like ANY of the characters? That’s my question….
|
|
|
Post by osdtdg on Oct 18, 2024 3:44:31 GMT
I think this is the type of show that requires a second viewing to get your head around it. Or, that is, the first time you will probably be quite confused but the second will give you a better understanding while you are able to focus more on comprehending everything already being familiar with the show. At least, thats how it was for me when I saw it in Sydney Agreed. Saw it in NYC and the story just felt odd. But the best sound design I’ve ever seen and the production design was opulent / gorgeous in the round. The cast recording make me really grow to love it. Are we supposed to like ANY of the characters? That’s my question…. I think the point is - being based on a section of War & Peace - that they're all very flawed humans and none of them of all that likely. I think the one character you are supposed to like (or feel bad for) is Natasha and maybe Sonya? I really did with the aussie cast, but that may be my fondness for them as actors and people more than the show itself lol
|
|
2,669 posts
Member is Online
|
Post by viserys on Oct 18, 2024 4:47:30 GMT
I think this is the type of show that requires a second viewing to get your head around it. Or, that is, the first time you will probably be quite confused but the second will give you a better understanding while you are able to focus more on comprehending everything already being familiar with the show. At least, thats how it was for me when I saw it in Sydney Very much this. I only started to pay attention to this because of Josh Groban back then (loved him as a singer, would have loved to see him on a Broadway stage) and I wasn't sure if the whole thing was a stroke of genius or treating Tolstoy with appalling lack of respect. Even then I thought I would need to see it live to judge it. But I didn't get around to it in NY and the CD gathered dust. I only picked it up again this year when the rumours for London started floating around and suddenly, from first listen, I loved it. Possibly because musical theatre has changed so much in the years since it opened - "meta shows" with modern sound and diverse casting are now very common and I've grown so endlessly tired of lame movie adaptations and shows with clunky bad lyrics, so all of a sudden I recognized what a stroke of genius it was to pluck one bit out of a huge novel and turn it into a musical of its own ad how clever the lyrics are and the whole conceit of constantly breaking the fourth wall. FWIW, I like almost everyone now except Anatole and perhaps Helene and of course Anatole serves a very important function. But yes, Natasha is a proper heroine in my book, young, innocent, let down by Andrey who's "not there" (in the words of the show), toyed with and dropped. And Pierre comes across as a curmudgeon first, but we realize that he's bogged down by a bad marriage ad perhaps early midlife crisis and sorting Natasha's affairs brings him back to life. These characters are so much better drawn and more complex than all the finger-snapping, yasss-kweeening bitchy teenagers of recent years.
|
|
1,558 posts
|
Post by showtoones on Oct 18, 2024 5:03:28 GMT
They could put Dame Judi and Johnny Bailey in the show and I wouldn’t go see it lol So the question is- why are you lurking in this thread? Because as much as I don’t like the show, I’m interested to hear people’s reactions to the casting. But you make a valid point lol
|
|
1,409 posts
|
Post by theatrefan62 on Oct 18, 2024 6:00:30 GMT
They could put Dame Judi and Johnny Bailey in the show and I wouldn’t go see it lol So the question is- why are you lurking in this thread? A tad hypocritical considering some of your past posts in other threads.
|
|
5,738 posts
|
Post by mrbarnaby on Oct 18, 2024 6:45:33 GMT
So the question is- why are you lurking in this thread? A tad hypocritical considering some of your past posts in other threads. Hardly. I only comment on shows that I have an interest in of some kind.
|
|
19,586 posts
|
Post by BurlyBeaR on Oct 18, 2024 7:03:49 GMT
A tad hypocritical considering some of your past posts in other threads. Hardly. I only comment on shows that I have an interest in of some kind. Is that why you’re in the Devil Wears Prada thread saying how awful it looks hmmmm? Either way, people can post in whatever thread they want without being challenged by other members so let’s leave them to it eh.
|
|
3,361 posts
|
Post by ceebee on Oct 18, 2024 7:21:18 GMT
Barnaby, Bear and the Great Thread of 2024.
|
|
5,738 posts
|
Post by mrbarnaby on Oct 18, 2024 8:43:19 GMT
Hardly. I only comment on shows that I have an interest in of some kind. Is that why you’re in the Devil Wears Prada thread saying how awful it looks hmmmm? Either way, people can post in whatever thread they want without being challenged by other members so let’s leave them to it eh. Yeah I wanted to see that show and was hopeful about it.. until I heard reports and saw the photos. Anyway Can’t wait for Maimuna to sing Sonya Alone and time stop
|
|