|
Post by c4ndyc4ne on May 16, 2023 22:45:43 GMT
Not sure about cast or creatives. She's a great performer but this is not the role for her in my opinion. Just the wrong side of 50 for me. She undoubtedly has a phenomenal voice. She could very well smash it, but it would be a very different Sunset. We need to pity Norma; she had it all but now she’s been left behind. I do not believe that this is the case with NS. She is still, if you will, smoking hot. You still definitely would. Many lines simply wouldn’t make sense. a fresh approach to a classic is a cause for intrigue no? in a way i'd be fascinated to see how the material holds up with a different take.
|
|
868 posts
|
Post by karloscar on May 17, 2023 0:09:33 GMT
Everything is so "iconic" these days it's a totally meaningless term. I'm wearing my iconic 🩲, to match my iconic 🧦 while eating iconic🍕! There are other more imaginative adjectives out there! You could say that about all kinds of words. It is used way more that it was 10 years ago, but in the sense of it's current meaning, I think OAT Evita was iconic. Not sure you can police other people's descriptive language - the words I would use to describe things are only ever IMHO. I am however glad that your pizza was iconic. Yum yum. the pizza was average at best, that's the point! My pants are fecking spectacular though!
|
|
490 posts
|
Post by WireHangers on May 17, 2023 0:19:58 GMT
If it is Nicole then the production is dead in the water. She won’t sell seats, while she’s easily one of the best vocalists out there she’s definitely one of the least famous pop stars. There are many roles I myself would love to see Nicole in but this isn’t it nor would many others.
My main issue is the alternate. No doubt they’ll go for someone without name recognition but unbelievable talent who’ll send us on the boards into space with her performance (any number of the industry names mentioned already would be inspired). If CZJ or someone of that calibre plays the role I’ll have to figure out a way to see both Normas during my short stint in London.
|
|
1,429 posts
|
Post by showtoones on May 17, 2023 0:53:11 GMT
When Nicole was in Cats, the whole run sold out. Now I’m not sure if it’s because of the nostalgia of Cats, it was the festive season, or if it was Nicole, but the combination of the three worked. That’s part of the reason why they brought the show back the following year with Beverley. I would never count Nicole out… And people in the US love her because she’s a judge on the masked singer.
|
|
|
Post by sph on May 17, 2023 1:31:34 GMT
Yes, Nicole Scherzinger wouldn't read as deluded when planning her "return" because she's still viable as an attractive, fairly young leading lady.
Norma just has to be a bit too old so that she's clearly missed her window. Brutal, but we're talking Hollywood in 1950 here.
|
|
18,837 posts
|
Post by BurlyBeaR on May 17, 2023 3:51:48 GMT
What’s Mandy Holden up to these days? 🙂
|
|
1,111 posts
|
Post by theatrefan62 on May 17, 2023 5:59:05 GMT
I'm amazed how dismissive people are of the importance of acting in Sunset. Nicole is completely unproven and inexperienced in that regard. Don't think the cringe yoghurt commercials count.
Also performing in concerts is completely different to 8 shows a week in a musical, and a heavily dramatic one at that. That's like saying a west end musical actor could go and do a PCD concert at the O2. Plus concerts aren't always live sung anyway.
I also agree I'm not sure of her pulling power. Cats was a long time ago and like someone said, it was a combination of a well loved piece returning, Christmas, and PCD still in recent memory. Since then she has really struggled to forge a career in the UK.
If this were someone from girls aloud or something people would be up in arms.
|
|
18,837 posts
|
Post by BurlyBeaR on May 17, 2023 6:34:03 GMT
The 8 shows a week thing is a non argument these days. Jessie Buckley, Lucie Jones and their producers have made not showing up for a full week the new normal. I agree with the rest though!
|
|
1,876 posts
|
Post by distantcousin on May 17, 2023 8:00:45 GMT
Rob Houchen has no edge whatsoever. I'm fed up with the many fresh faced pretty boys cast in that role.
The character needs to be rougher around the edges. Danny Mac was excellent. As was Ben Goddard in the 00's.
|
|
1,876 posts
|
Post by distantcousin on May 17, 2023 8:01:58 GMT
I'm amazed how dismissive people are of the importance of acting in Sunset. Nicole is completely unproven and inexperienced in that regard. Don't think the cringe yoghurt commercials count. Also performing in concerts is completely different to 8 shows a week in a musical, and a heavily dramatic one at that. That's like saying a west end musical actor could go and do a PCD concert at the O2. Plus concerts aren't always live sung anyway. I also agree I'm not sure of her pulling power. Cats was a long time ago and like someone said, it was a combination of a well loved piece returning, Christmas, and PCD still in recent memory. Since then she has really struggled to forge a career in the UK. If this were someone from girls aloud or something people would be up in arms. Her Cats pulling power was off the back of being watched by millions every Saturday night on The X Factor for a number of years. That era is ancient history now.
|
|
577 posts
|
Post by christya on May 17, 2023 9:37:48 GMT
Nicole has a beautiful voice, but if anything that's not a recommendation for this role, unless she can change it up a little by actually acting the part. Glenn Close is not a fantastic singer by any means, but she has a serviceable voice with a good range to it, and the acting ability to take that and make a fantastic Norma. After all, there's a reason Norma didn't make it in talkies. Someone like Nicole would probably sound lovely, and be utterly unbelievable as Norma.
|
|
269 posts
|
Post by ilovewemusicals on May 17, 2023 10:06:51 GMT
And now, Mr DeMille, I'm ready for the official announcement.
|
|
905 posts
|
Post by max on May 17, 2023 11:00:15 GMT
I guess, if Nicole, her beauty would mean we're watching Norma's deluded memory of her former powers. How would that be clear? The older/real Norma wandering the stage in ghostly fashion, lol
Okay, it's a terrible Idea, but I can imagine it happening.
|
|
18,837 posts
|
Post by BurlyBeaR on May 17, 2023 11:03:09 GMT
Or they can just make her up in a way that makes her look grotesque. It’s theatre darlings! Lights! Greasepaint! Smoke and mirrors!
|
|
905 posts
|
Post by max on May 17, 2023 11:04:46 GMT
Retitled:
"Sunset Boulevard - Next To Norma"
Strapline ".
"Nothing's wrong with being 44"
|
|
905 posts
|
Post by max on May 17, 2023 11:08:30 GMT
Or they can just make her up in a way that makes her look grotesque. It’s theatre darlings! Lights! Greasepaint! Smoke and mirrors! True, but a directorial note to "sing it a bit more sh*t darling" slightly defeats the point of casting.
|
|
1,111 posts
|
Post by theatrefan62 on May 17, 2023 11:13:17 GMT
I'm amazed how dismissive people are of the importance of acting in Sunset. Nicole is completely unproven and inexperienced in that regard. Don't think the cringe yoghurt commercials count. Also performing in concerts is completely different to 8 shows a week in a musical, and a heavily dramatic one at that. That's like saying a west end musical actor could go and do a PCD concert at the O2. Plus concerts aren't always live sung anyway. I also agree I'm not sure of her pulling power. Cats was a long time ago and like someone said, it was a combination of a well loved piece returning, Christmas, and PCD still in recent memory. Since then she has really struggled to forge a career in the UK. If this were someone from girls aloud or something people would be up in arms. Her Cats pulling power was off the back of being watched by millions every Saturday night on The X Factor for a number of years. That era is ancient history now. That's true I'd forgotten about xfactor.
|
|
1,111 posts
|
Post by theatrefan62 on May 17, 2023 11:14:54 GMT
Rob Houchen has no edge whatsoever. I'm fed up with the many fresh faced pretty boys cast in that role. The character needs to be rougher around the edges. Danny Mac was excellent. As was Ben Goddard in the 00's. Completely agree on the first part, Joe is often underrated and written off as a pretty boy role. Disagree on Danny Mac though, he was more pretty boy without bite. I though Michael Xavier was too 'nice' too.
|
|
|
Post by capybara on May 17, 2023 11:21:21 GMT
What’s Mandy Holden up to these days? 🙂 Doing up more villas in Italy with Alan Carr!
|
|
865 posts
|
Post by BVM on May 17, 2023 11:29:40 GMT
The casting of Norma Desmond certainly evokes very strong feelings. I guess it is one of the all time great musical theatre roles.
Would I be committing heresy in these parts by saying I didn't like Glenn?! (It's ok, I already know the answer....). I understand people thought her characterisation was next level but for me it couldn't detract from the anxiety wondering how she was gonna cope with the musical crescendo and final notes of With One Look and As If We Never Said Goodbye (alas she didn't nail either). I dunno. These are such incredible songs that I just want to hear them sung with perfect pitch, power and tone. For that reason I'd definitely take a Nicole over a Glenn. (Caveat is that I did see her at the ENO just after she'd got back from being off and on the IV drip so maybe she wasn't at her best. Also all the acting in the world couldn't translate to my million miles away (100 quid plus) upper circle seat. I do have the OBC though and personally for me, her singing voice just doesn't have the most pleasant quality. Anyway, as I said, I do appreciate I am fully in the minority here).
Patti LuPone was my favourite of the "Nunn's Normas" (shame she's gone increasingly angry about everything in life ever since) closely followed by Betty Buckley - both of whom for me proved that you can be am amazing singer and actor. EP a very close third. Absolutely nailed the vocal. Characterisation was excellent but just a modicum too camp.
I wish I could remember better what Faith Brown was like in the RUG tour. Only went once.
I liked Kathryn Evans in the CRH version. And Ria was Ria in the most recent tour. I liked her and she can certainly sing it, but was also slightly too camp - much of this may have been in the direction though I guess.
Anyway, if these rumours are true, then I await with great anticipation who it will be!
|
|
3,784 posts
|
Post by anthony40 on May 17, 2023 11:30:27 GMT
What’s Mandy Holden up to these days? 🙂 She's on Heart Radio every morning and Britain's Got Talent judging.
|
|
865 posts
|
Post by BVM on May 17, 2023 11:36:25 GMT
Agree with what others have said that Joe is often played by too typical romantic male lead types.
I thought the original Joe, Kevin Anderson was perfection. He was also very underrated and almost invisible what with all the Patti LuPone drama. His Joe was cynical, understated, brooding, dark, sexy and slightly mysterious. They guy they then cast in LA/NYC was very much more typical alpha male, as was Barrowman in the West End. Which is less how I imagine the character to be.
|
|
|
Post by A.Ham on May 17, 2023 11:37:26 GMT
Please not Amanda Holden!! I’m afraid that would definitely rule this out for me.
|
|
1,199 posts
|
Post by theatrefan77 on May 17, 2023 11:39:38 GMT
Totally agree with BVM. Kevin Anderson was the best Joe. Just perfect and worked really well with LuPone. For me it was just the perfect match.
|
|
1,111 posts
|
Post by theatrefan62 on May 17, 2023 11:40:40 GMT
Totally agree. Kevin Anderson was the best Joe. Just perfect and worked really well with LuPone. For me it was just the perfect match. No a fan of Patti personally but completely agree on Kevin, I don't think he has been matched.
|
|
1,876 posts
|
Post by distantcousin on May 17, 2023 11:44:10 GMT
Retitled: "Sunset Boulevard - Next To Norma" Strapline ". "Nothing's wrong with being 44" Not to be that person, BUT Patti, Glenn, Betty and Elaine were ALL around that age when they first donned the turban....
|
|
1,876 posts
|
Post by distantcousin on May 17, 2023 11:45:26 GMT
Rob Houchen has no edge whatsoever. I'm fed up with the many fresh faced pretty boys cast in that role. The character needs to be rougher around the edges. Danny Mac was excellent. As was Ben Goddard in the 00's. Completely agree on the first part, Joe is often underrated and written off as a pretty boy role. Disagree on Danny Mac though, he was more pretty boy without bite. I though Michael Xavier was too 'nice' too. OK. He worked for me. But I'd never seen him in anything else. Xavier was awful. Played to the gallery the entire time, and clearly wanted to be "liked" by the audience.
|
|
|
Post by newyorkcityboy on May 17, 2023 11:46:46 GMT
The casting of Norma Desmond certainly evokes very strong feelings. I guess it is one of the all time great musical theatre roles. Would I be committing heresy in these parts by saying I didn't like Glenn?! (It's ok, I already know the answer....). I understand people thought her characterisation was next level but for me it couldn't detract from the anxiety wondering how she was gonna cope with the musical crescendo and final notes of With One Look and As If We Never Said Goodbye (alas she didn't nail either). I dunno. These are such incredible songs that I just want to hear them sung with perfect pitch, power and tone. For that reason I'd definitely take a Nicole over a Glenn. (Caveat is that I did see her at the ENO just after she'd got back from being off and on the IV drip so maybe she wasn't at her best. Also all the acting in the world couldn't translate to my million miles away (100 quid plus) upper circle seat. I do have the OBC though and personally for me, her singing voice just doesn't have the most pleasant quality. Anyway, as I said, I do appreciate I am fully in the minority here). Patti LuPone was my favourite of the "Nunn's Normas" (shame she's gone increasingly angry about everything in life ever since) closely followed by Betty Buckley - both of whom for me proved that you can be am amazing singer and actor. EP a very close third. Absolutely nailed the vocal. Characterisation was excellent but just a modicum too camp. I wish I could remember better what Faith Brown was like in the RUG tour. Only went once. I liked Kathryn Evans in the CRH version. And Ria was Ria in the most recent tour. I liked her and she can certainly sing it, but was also slightly too camp - much of this may have been in the direction though I guess. Anyway, if these rumours are true, then I await with great anticipation who it will be! Faith was good, her voice the complete opposite of Glenn, very warm with earthy tones. I have the CD of her versions of the songs somewhere, I think.
|
|
594 posts
|
Post by og on May 17, 2023 11:46:47 GMT
Please not Amanda Holden!! I’m afraid that would definitely rule this out for me. They'd have to light it all in LED - no tungsten - or her face will melt under the heat
|
|
1,111 posts
|
Post by theatrefan62 on May 17, 2023 11:47:03 GMT
Bradley Jaden as Joe maybe
|
|